Utah Native Plant Society

The posts contained herein are intended to be informational, and any opinions expressed are mine alone.




Saturday, December 30, 2023

UDWR acknowledges the importance of the ESA but also wants police to kill urban deer

Importance of the Endangered Species Act acknowledged by UDWR:

The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources (UDWR) has been devoting itself to delisting plant (and animal) species formally listed under the very important Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA) and has not ever to my knowledge ever supported new listings. Quite the reverse.

Yet in a news report piece published on December 27, 2023 with respect to the 50th anniversary of the ESA, a UDWR representative acknowledges that the Act has  "has prevented the extinction of hundreds of [imperiled] species" and that it has also helped "promote the recovery of many species that were near extinction."

This is a great but is also a rather shocking acknowledgment by an agency that has done nothing but pushback against and complain about the ESA, and that has embarked on an ambitious statewide program of introducing non-native mountain goats that are negatively impacting high-elevation ecosystems, and an agency that has traditionally opposed the protection of wolves despite the science that indicates the very important role they play.

The piece goes on to mention the 17 wildlife species currently listed under the ESA that occur in Utah.  Yet there is no mention of the currently 25 listed plant species that also occur in Utah.  The importance of plant species in general is never given the attention that they deserve.  We would not exist without them, nor would any wildlife.  Healthy and diverse ecosystems rely on healthy native plant populations.

Related stories re: the 50th anniversary of the ESA:

https://www.upr.org/2023-12-24/the-endangered-species-act-turns-50

https://www.upr.org/2023-12-24/the-santa-cruz-island-dudleya-is-an-endangered-species-act-success-story

https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/publications/earthonline/endangered-earth-online-no1225.html

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/01/02/2023-28935/50th-anniversary-of-the-endangered-species-act-2023

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/money-endangered-species-goes-small-number-creatures-leaving-others-li-rcna131680

(this last reference discusses the plight of plants that are typically short-changed)


UDWR and urban deer:

As a curiosity completely unrelated to the above, the same UDWR representative on the same date and in another news report indicates that the UDWR has "authorized" city police to "cull" urban deer.  So much for the sanctity of wildlife.  We are living in their habitat, not the other way around.  If they are bothering someone's flower garden (but in winter, they are just looking for something to browse, mainly grass) that really doesn't justify killing them.  That they can cause accidents is true but normally that is because drivers tend to drive too fast and don't pay attention. Somehow we do have to find a way to live with the natural world and not do what we do best (i.e. kill anything that moves, and destroy natural open spaces).  That we have failed to give them corridors to areas where they should be able to freely roam in an attempt to survive is our fault, not theirs. There is also considerable concern about the risk of someone being shot with a bullet or an arrow while attempts are made to cull herds.  Police officers are not trained wildlife hunters or trappers.  City police should not take on this responsibility that UDWR has "authorized" (which likely also exceeds UDWR's authority).







Friday, December 22, 2023

Idaho dam proposal threatens the Great Salt Lake

Pacificorp's newly proposed dam in the Oneida Narrows will likely negatively impact the already beleaguered Great Salt Lake:

The Bear River is the major source of water for the Great Salt Lake (and its ecosystems) which of course is already in serious trouble.  This proposed dam would be the second dam on this section of the river.

While the project location is in Idaho, Utahns need to weigh in on yet another ill-advised dam that will likely have serious downstream consequences.  Dams are short-lived and create ecological collapse.  It is exactly these types of projects that have contributed to the shrinking of the Great Salt Lake, the ultimate loss of which would have devastating human health as well as disastrous environmental consequences for wildlife and related native plant ecosystems.

Comments are due by December 26.

Project background information:

https://www.idahostatejournal.com/community/public-comment-sought-on-proposal-for-new-oneida-narrows-dam-input-due-dec-26/article_dc86c271-fba8-59a3-b6e2-f390519fba9c.html

https://www.pacificorp.com/energy/storage/oneida.html

Friends of Great Salt Lake newsletter (see page 16):

https://www.fogsl.org/newsroom/newsletters/74-2023-winter/file


Advocacy group opposing this project:

https://www.oneidanarrows.org/

Their petition:

https://chng.it/BM465s8Qvz


Ferc comment link:

https://www.ferc.gov/how-file-comment